Featured post

When out fossil hunting...

So I thought I would do a post about things to remember when out and about doing your own fossil hunts, hopefully you'll find it helpfu...

Saturday 13 August 2016

The Difference Between...Rugose, Tabulate and Scleractinian corals

This is going to be a series of posts that look at fossils that are either difficult to
Rugose coral. Image credit: paleo.cortland.edu
differentiate or can be easily confused.

This post will look at three types of corals; rugose, tabulate and scleractinian.

First of all, there is the geological context of these corals, in partcular what age the sediments will be that you find them in. Rugose corals are found in Ordovician to Permian sediments, being wiped out at the Permian extinction. Tabulate corals also have the same range, so this would not be useful if you were trying to differentiate the two using geology. However, scleractinian corals have a younger range, from the Triassic to recent times. giving a feature to differentiate this coral from the other two.
Tabulate coral. Image credit: fossillady.wordpress.com

Scleractinian coral. Image credit: hoopermuseum.earthsci.carleton.ca
When trying to identify if your coral is tabulate or not, look at whether or not your fossil is colonial or solitary. Tabulate fossils are almost exclusively colonial. It's difficult to differentiate Scleractinian and Rugose fossils this way as both have colonial and solitary species.

Scleractinian and Rugose corals both also have well developed septa, so this cannot be used to tell the difference. But again, tabulate corals have weak or absent septa. The tabulae can be used to identify Scleractinians easily as they are usually absent in these corals. They are well developed in tabulate and most rugose possess tabulae.

Symmetry is useful for differentiating Rugose corals from tabulate and scleractinians. The symmetry in rugose is bilateral, meaning that two identical halves can be created, humans are bilaterally symmetrical. However, tabulates and scleractinians have radial symmetry.

Scleractinian skeletons are made from aragonite which is unstable in fossilisation, whereas the tabulate and rugose corals have calcite skeletons.

Summary:
Rugose: Ordovician to Permian. Well developed septa. Bilaterally symmetrical. Colonial and solitary. Most possess tabulae. Calcite skeleton.

Tabulate: Ordovician to Permian. Weak or absent septa. Radial symmetry. Always colonial. Well developed tabulae. Calcite skeleton.

Scleractinian: Triassic to Recent. Well developed septa. Radial symmetry. Colonial and solitary. Absent tabulae. Aragonite skeleton.

Did you find this helpful? Let me know what you think in the comments.

18 comments:

Unknown said...

Helpful. In identification and age difference.

Jack Prowting said...

Thank you, I'm glad you found it helpful!

Unknown said...

Great

Sepia said...

So would UNPAIRED septa, as in tube anemones and black corals, be rugose or just an odd kind of scleractinian coral? I may be out of my league, no pun intended, but trying to understand differences between black corals and tube anemones. So cool that this site exists, thank you!

Jack Prowting said...

Although the anemones and corals are both anthozoans, anemones are of the order Actiniaria thus separate form the order Scleractinia. I'm very glad you found and enjoyed this page! Thank you

Unknown said...

Its helpful to me,between the three of them. Thank you so much. I think I should visit this page often. 👍👍

Unknown said...

Love This Page. In college and this really helps.

Unknown said...

Very helpful

Anonymous said...

This helped SO much! I was doing a project on Lophophyllidium Proliferum (of Rugose), and this helped a lot.

Unknown said...

Very helpful.... Thank you

Unknown said...

Very helpful
Thanks very much

Laura said...

How common is this to dine in your backyard?

Laura said...

*find

Anonymous said...

Very helpful

George said...

Yes, this was helpful. I presume the calcitic nature of both Rugosa and Tabularia makes it diffucult to conside them as ancestral to Scleratinia?

Anonymous said...

Very cool stuff 👍👍👍👍👌👌👌👌

RESMAYVARY said...

-I found one a couple of days ago . I have no clue what to do with it .

RESMAYVARY said...

-its covered in this like super brown sand on it it comes off but it'll stain my brush like if it was a brown eyeshadow